Scotland: Improved performance by road maintenance companies

carousel control up

  • Performance Audit Group  - 1
  • Performance Audit Group  - 2
  • Performance Audit Group  - 3

carousel control bottom

Image 1 of 3 Performance Audit Group - 1

Our report examines 155 areas of performance and over 92% were found to be excellent, good or fair
Donald Bell
Halcrow project director

September 2009

An independent report into the maintenance of Scotland’s vital trunk roads and motorways has found that contractors are putting in a strong performance and continuing to improve services.

The report was published by Halcrow, who lead the Performance Audit Group commission for Transport Scotland. Halcrow’s expert team of engineers, supported by accountants PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP, carried out over almost 70 detailed audits of contractors BEAR, Amey and Scotland TranServ in 2008/09, as well as visiting over 1,000 road maintenance sites.

Donald Bell, Halcrow’s project director said:

“Our team travelled across Scotland throughout the year to visit routes, roadworks and depots, as well as monitoring the contractors’ management systems, to assess performance in maintaining these vital arteries. Our report examines 155 areas of performance and over 92% were found to be excellent, good or fair.”

Graham Edmond, Head of Network Maintenance for Transport Scotland, said:

“We have worked closely with PAG over the last year to continually monitor and improve the performance of our Operating Companies. We are pleased with the success of these efforts as reported in the Annual Report which we will jointly build on over the next year.”

The report notes particularly strong performance in health and safety, co-ordinating roadworks and dealing with emergencies. Using well-developed quality management systems, any areas for improvement in the contractors’ performance are monitored closely by the Performance Audit Group and Transport Scotland.

Donald Bell added:

“This strong performance reflects the culture of continuous improvement and teamwork developed by the contractors with Transport Scotland.”

Related content

  • Scotland 

    Halcrow is one of the leading consultancies in Scotland.

  • Performance audit group, Scotland 

    Maintaining the £12 billion Scottish trunk road network to a high standard is key to connecting communities and vital to the country’s economy.

  • Performance audit group 

    PAG's mission is to audit, monitor and review Scotland's trunk road contracts, raising standards and encouraging best practice...

Contact details

Press office